Review: Heartbreaking ‘Hadestown’ Is Fated to Win Over New Hearts

By SHARON EBERSON

The myth of Orpheus and Eurydice has inspired rhapsodic retellings since ancient times, and as the musical Hadestown continues to prove, 21st-century audiences also can’t get enough of the star-crossed lovers.

As the show now at the Benedum Center opens, Rudy Foster exudes effervescence as the Greek god Hermes, belying the tragedy about to unfold. But don’t blame your lively guide to hell and back. The Anais Mitchell musical, which began as a 2010 concept album, reminds us over and over, “It’s a sad tale, it’s a tragedy / It’s a sad song.”

Despite its upbeat moments, this is not a feel-good musical. The journey is in the title.

Rudy Foster as Hermes, center, in the Hadestown tour at the Benedum Center through November 1, 2026. (Image: Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade)

What remains remarkable about Hadestown is its prescience for the here and now. Listen to the song “We Build the Wall,” devoid of its theatrical, hellish context, and you can’t miss the echoes of the border wall that the president started talking about in 2014.

For first-timers, the current production maintains a few of the thrills that made Hadestown the winner of eight Tony Awards, including Best Musical. The tour at the Benedum Center through November 1, 2026, has been ongoing since October 2024 — the Broadway tour that was here in 2022 was more a reflection of the original Tony-winning set design and staging. For example, the Hadestown now in Pittsburgh lacks a rotating platform, and the balcony — Hades’ perch — is centrally located and overlooks the world from a less intimidating height.

The choreography has been retooled, based on David Neumann’s organically integrated original work, and the menace here is achieved by the presence and bass of Nickolaus Colón as Hades, along with glaring lights, stage fog, and the singular change of backdrop, from stuccoed wall to deepest red.

The myth-turned-modern folktale features a score with Americana-infused New Orleans jazz and blues, sometimes sultry, sometimes “livin’ it up,” with the well-oiled onstage band among the production’s highlights.

If you don’t know the Orpheus-Eurydice myth, and there were some gasps during the climax on opening night Tuesday, there are spoilers ahead. Remember, though, that the musical is “a sad tale … a sad song,” and that refrain informs the outcome.

In most versions of the Greek myth, Eurydice is happily just wed to Orpheus when she accidentally steps on a viper while fleeing another man’s advances. Here, starving and unintentionally ignored by Orpheus, she is seduced by Hades’ promise of a better world down-under.

In the lead-up, the innocent Orpheus (Jose Contreras, who poses a tenor consistent with Broadway original Reeve Carney) can’t get a magical tune out of his head, one that he believes will bring endless spring to a cold, barren world.

Jose Contreras as Orpheus) sings “Wait for Me” in Hadestown.
(Image: Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade)

When he falls hard for worldly Eurydice (Hawa Kamara), he gives her hope for a better tomorrow. However, when he gets lost in completing his song, ignoring Eurydice’s plight, her trust fades.

My son, who knows the myth but was seeing Hadestown for  the first time, became fixated on Eurydice’s “choice,” which changes so much about the myth. Hades finds her destitute, at the end of hope, and sells death as an escape from poverty, hunger and pain. In the myth, as in life, there is no going back from suicide.

When Orpheus learns of Eurydice’s decision (seduction?) to join Hades in hell, he determines to follow her via a back way, filled with hardships. That leads to perhaps the best-known sequence from the show, the dance of the swinging lamps, as Orpheus sings “Wait for Me” during his dangerous descent.

Throughout the show, three malevolent Fates add to the couple’s obstacles. The trio is endlessly entertaining and provides beautiful backing vocals, along with a hard-working, triple-threat chorus. Among the Fates, Miriam Navarette stepped in for Namisa Mdlalose Bizana as Persephone after intermission.

Nickolaus Colón as Hades confronts Hawa Kamara’s Eurydice, watched
by Fates (from left) Jayna Westcoatt, Miriam Navarrete and Gia Keddy.
(Image: Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade)

As Hades’ tipsy, benevolent wife, bound to the Underworld but for a few weeks each year, Persephone provides some of the liveliest moments in the show, with “Livin’ It Up on Top” and second-act opener “Our Lady of the Underground.”

Musically, this Hadestown has plenty to offer, particularly with Foster’s Hermes leading the way, and the Fates ever-present. Some of the drama and technical wizardry I look forward to from previous productions is MIA, but with an irresistible score and inherent timely update, the tragic story is fated to be told again and again.

TICKETS AND DETAILS

Hadestown is at the Benedum Center, Downtown, through November 1, 2026. Tickets: https://trustarts.org/production/75349/hadestown



Categories: Arts and Ideas, Reviews

Tags: , , , ,

2 replies

  1. Audience members gasing doesn’t mean they didn’t come in knowing the story. I knew what would happen but gasped both times I saw the show because of how dramatically the moment is portrayed.

    • Thank you for you comment. I found it less dramatic in this production because of the staging, but I shouldn’t make assumptions about others.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *