Review: Christian Borle’s Hometown Cabaret Rides High on Waves of Laughter, Tears and Endless Well of Talent

By SHARON EBERSON

What a delicious Christian Borle feast we were treated to by the Pittsburgh native in his homecoming song-and-nostalgia fest on Monday at the Trust Cabaret.  Borle had not appeared on a local stage since touring with the companies of Footloose and West Side Story in the 1990s. He returned a two-time Tony Award winner, delighting two sold-out concerts at the intimate Greer Cabaret Theater, where his biting sense of humor and endless well of musical thater talent mingled with sweetly emotional responses to reconnecting with old friends and mentors.

Christian Borle’s Trust Cabaret set offered a mix of musical theater comedy, drama and nostalgia.

The cabaret, created with accompanist Nate Patten, was like none he had done before, because it was geared to his hometown, including paying tribute to the man who witnessed his first kiss, Dan Brill, who cast him as Will Parker in Oklahoma! at Shady Side Academy. A Fox Chapel native, Borle’s education took him from Falk School, to St. Edmund’s and Shady Side before he blossomed at Carnegie Mellon University, under the tutelage of legendary vocal instructor Gary Kline.

A highlight of the cabaret was Borle bringing Kline to the stage for a duet on “Lily’s Eyes” (from the Secret Garden). Borle, who teared up several times at the 9:30 p.m. performance, repeatedly expressed his gratitude to Brill and Kline and all those that shaped his career after he left Pittsburgh.

Borle learned his lessons well, and showcased all of them in one number: the Beauty and the Beast Prologue, voicing not only Belle and the core characters, but every townsperson who stopped to say, “Bonjour.” The vocal gymnastics began with a joke that he would be joined on stage by other singers and the CMU Drama Class of 2027 , but because air traffic had been grounded … voila, we were treated to a solo masterpiece.

Another funny bit came with homework. We were told to watch Leonard Bernstein’s “chain-smoking meltdown” in trying to coax the performance he wanted from acclaimed tenor José Carreras, whom he had chosen to play Tony on the 1984 Deutsche Grammophon recording of West Side Story. I did my homework. It is painful to watch, but hilarious with Borle’s context — his earliest professional role was as Riff in a West Side Story tour, when his Tony’s included Max Von Essen and Steven Pasquale. But of all the singers Bernstein could have chosen, it was Carreras he wanted, which allowed, the 53-year-old Borle to re-create the 34-year-old Spaniard trying to get the inflections and nuances of a 17-year-old Polish kid singing, “Something’s Coming.”

The loss earlier this year of William Finn (A New Brain, Falsettos) hit particularly hard, but Borle celebrated Finn’s work with a song from the underappreciated Elegies: A Song Cycle, “Mark’s All-Male Thanksgiving.” A favorite song dating to his college days, much to the consternation of his classmates who listened to him sing it over and over, is Finn’s “What More Can I Say?” from Falsettoes. It has been 10 years since that acclaimed revival starring Borle, Andrew Rannells, Brandon Uranowitz, and Stephanie Block, prompting a reunion-concert celebration that started at Carnegie Hall and will move to London in February.

Offering that he has played several “preening narcissistic sociopaths,” Borle included “It’s Hard to Be the Bard,” a song from one such character, his Tony-winning role as William Shakespeare in Something Rotten!, and the Dentist Song from Little Shop of Horrors (like Beauty and the Beast, a reminder of the talents of the late Howard Ashman).

Saying he and his mother shared an appreciation for Rupert Holmes, Borle’s comedic flare almost did-in his expensive eyeglass frames on the song “Nearsighted” (new to me, but now on my playlist). He didn’t forget Smash fans, singing, “Don’t Say Yes Until I Finish Talking,” featuring lines like, “Tomatoes like her must be put in their place.”

A look-back on his career included his classic “That’s on eBay commercial,” and that Borle was a Wicked ensemble member when the musical was in development – his big line was, “The Wizard will see you now!” However, he chose instead to leave that juggernaut and replace Gavin Creel as the leading man in Thoroughly Modern Millie. From Millie, he sang, “What Do I Need With Love?” (along with the little zing, “And do you know who has never hired me again? Stephen Schwartz.”)

Christian Borle’s Trust Cabaret shows weren’t his only stops in Pittsburgh. He also met with students from Carnegie Mellon and Point Park Universities.

The tone shifted with each shared memory and song, from the opening “All I Care About Is Love” to the closing Finished (almost) with the song “Somewhere Down the Road”:

But somewhere down the road / Our roads are gonna cross again … Hell yes, please.

But wait, there was more. Being back in his hometown was never far from the mind of the award-winning performer wearing the Comeback Kid/Steel City T-shirt. The late-night cabaret got a bonus song and a sing-along, “You’ll Be Back,” King George’s implied dare to his “loyal, royal subjects” from Hamilton.

I had craved for Christian Borle to share a song from Bye Bye, Birdie, which he starred in at the Kennedy Center between a Tony-nomination for Some Like It Hot and Tammy Faye. Maybe next time. If Borle is back on stage, from here to Broadway, I know this loyal subject wouldn’t miss it for the world.



Categories: Celebrity News, Feature Stories, Our Posts, Reviews

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%%footer%%